Blue Buffalo vs Purina Pro Plan: Which Is Better Value?
Two mid-premium brands with very different approaches. Blue Buffalo markets itself as the "natural" choice at $11.80/kg, while Purina Pro Plan focuses on research-backed nutrition at $10.90/kg. Let's settle this once and for all.
Quick Comparison
Factor Blue Buffalo Purina Pro Plan Price per kg $11.80 $10.90 Monthly cost (70lb dog) $74 $68 First ingredient Deboned chicken Chicken Protein % 26% 26% Research backing Minimal Extensive (96 years) Recall history Multiple (melamine, vitamin D, salmonella) Minimal Best for Natural ingredient marketing Overall best value
Purina Pro Plan wins this comparison hands down. It's cheaper ($68 vs $74/month for a 70lb dog), has better research backing, a cleaner recall record, and comparable ingredients. Blue Buffalo's "natural" marketing doesn't justify the higher price or the recall concerns. The only reason to choose Blue Buffalo over Purina Pro Plan is if your dog specifically does better on a grain-free formula and you've tried Pro Plan without success. Otherwise, Purina Pro Plan is the smarter choice.Our Take
Better research, cleaner history, lower price, comparable nutrition. If you're deciding between these two, Purina Pro Plan is the clear winner for most dogs.The Verdict
Winner: Purina Pro Plan
See exactly how much each brand would cost for your specific breed and weight.Compare Costs for Your Dog